Thursday, January 24, 2008

Firearms Safety - - and a notable Negligent Discharge

First, a hat tip to Grant Cunningham over at the Revolver Liberation Alliance blog for providing the original link to a truly instructive story about a negligent discharge. Mr. C's blog is enjoyable reading for anyone interested in revolvers. I admire his writings about wheel guns in general, and his custom work in particular, but I respectfully disagree with some of his personal interpretations. More on that later.

Click HERE for the link to a brutally frank ND report, written by the unfortunate who self-victimized his own person.
Please be advised: Some of the images included depict actual gunshot wounds. As such wounds go, these are not particularly gory, but they ARE graphic, and might take some folks by surprise. The writer confesses his own negligence and tells us of the aftermath. It is noted that, for a gunshot wound inflicted with a major caliber handgun, with high performance ammunition, at VERY close range, this one is fairly minor. Nonetheless, the aftermath was painful, traumatic, and expensive. It should be a lesson to us all.

The writer/victim points out the difference between an Accidental Discharge (AD) and a Negligent Discharge (ND.) He also repeats the FOUR RULES OF FIREARMS SAFETY in pretty much their original form, with some valuable elaborations. As it is ALWAYS in order to stress safety, I'll list them again:

Jeff Cooper's Rules of Gun Safety


The above are pretty much “the original,” as I was taught them when I attended Gunsite back in 1980. They have been paraphrased a number of times, but as long as the sense of these is maintained, the purpose will be accomplished. “The Rules” are one of Jeff Cooper's true contributions to the world of shooting.

If these rules are taken to heart and strictly observed, safe gun handling is assured. Many years ago, the firearms industry, in cooperation with the National Rifle Association, promulgated “The Ten Commandments of Gun Safety.” These were okay, and far preferable to no codified rules at all. I submit that The Four Rules are truly superior, in that they are simple, easy to remember and easy to teach. If we truly make them part of our thinking when dealing with firearms, there will be no tragic accidents, no silly mistakes, and no unintended injuries.

I hope you'll take time to read Greg Morrison's commentary on The Four Rules. He changes nothing, but does provide an expanded and valuable perspective.

The disagreement I have with Mr. Cunningham's writings is his rearrangement and rephrasing of these valued safety rules. Perhaps it is not so large a matter as it seems to me, that we should not be revisionist with other individuals' writing. Maybe it's just too soon after Colonel Cooper's death, and I might think differently later. Who knows?


HollyB said...

Call me pedantic if you wish, but changing Colonel Cooper's Four Rules of Gun Safety is akin to changing the Ten Commandments. It's as blasphemous as changing the words on those tablets Moses brought down from the mount.

I'm not saying this because I'm your wife. I'm saying this because I am a "True Believer" in the Colonel's Four Rules. And every other writing of his I've had the pleasure of reading.

Anonymous said...

Blasphemy? Nah.

"RULE IV: BE SURE OF YOUR TARGET" is far too vague.

"Know your target and what lies beyond it" is much more easily comprehended.

It's not about religion; it's about safety.

Old NFO said...

Thanks for an excellent post! We all need to be reminded of the rules lest we become complacent, as happened here. Col Cooper wrote in what I would call a tech/military style, in many cases making the assumption the reader would have a familiarity with the subject matter. It's very sparse, but also very clear (at elast to me). Trying to 'explain' his writings only muddies the water as far as I'm concerned.

Fyremandoug said...

JPG thanks for that post I can't ever pound this Info into peoples heads enuff, I feel I am on my soap box most of the time but every once in a while some one understands and comprehends the lecture

Seth from Massachusetts said...

I have been handling guns for over 30 years now and in that time I can recall no accidental discharges, but four neglegant ones. None of these caused any damage because the safe direction rule was being carefully obeyed in each case.

Assrot said...

I personally agree with you and think the 4 rules are plenty. If followed to the letter, good gun safety is assured and nobody will get hurt.

While the 10 commandments of gun safety or whatever else they are called are good as well, its a long list to remember and can be confusing to the beginner.

I have always believed in keeping things simple. The simpler they are the easier they are to become habits. Gun safety is not rocket science and I think Cooper's 4 rules work just fine.

Gunner Jacky said...

We should follow all the primary rules of gun safety. We should maintain the safe direction of the gun so that even if it were to go off it would not cause injury or damage.
Firearms Safety Training MA.